I do have to back up in time a bit. I just noticed I missed some crucial passages, namely where Jesus first calls the fishermen to follow him. (I’m sure this won’t be the last time I skip something by mistake.)
At any rate, these passages are a little difficult to harmonize, namely Matthew and Mark with Luke.
Any harmonization is purely speculative, but it is my guess that the events in Luke happened first, and that the events in Matthew and Mark happened shortly thereafter, perhaps a day or two later.
One day Jesus was trying to teach, but was getting pressed all the way back to the water by the huge crowds that were surrounding him.
Seeing Peter and his friends washing their nets nearby, he got into one of their boats and asked them to go out from shore a bit, and he taught from the water.
I’m not sure how much Peter and his friends wanted to do that. They’d just had a fruitless night of fishing, were tired, and probably wanted to go home. But they did as Jesus asked.
After Jesus finished teaching, however, he told them to go out further into the water to catch some fish.
At that point, Peter reached his limit. He was tired, discouraged, and wanted to waste no more time fishing this day. He certainly didn’t want to take any advice on fishing from a carpenter.
So he said,
Master, we’ve worked hard all night and haven’t caught anything. (Luke 5:5a)
But Jesus never wavered and just looked at Peter until he finally mumbled,
But because you say so, I will let down the nets. (Luke 5:5b)
So Peter and his friends went out, probably totally embarrassed. After all, nobody went fishing at that time of day. There were simply no fish to be had, and their friends in the other boat were probably all laughing at them for following Jesus’ advice.
But when they let down the nets, there were so many fish, Peter soon called his friends in the other boat to come help them, and there were so many fish, both boats began to sink.
At first, Peter was probably exuberant. But then it sank down in his heart what had just happened. He realized that this Jesus was much more than just an ordinary teacher.
And so he fell to his knees, and said,
Go away from me, Lord; I am a sinful man! (Luke 5:8)
But Jesus answered,
Don’t be afraid; from now on you will catch men. (Luke 5:10)
Again this is pure speculation, but I’m guessing that Luke compressed what happened next.
I’m guessing that they all went home that night. It’s possible that Jesus wanted them to reflect on all that had happened and the words he had spoken to them.
And then, perhaps the next morning, or shortly thereafter, while Peter and Andrew were fishing, and while James and John were mending their nets, Jesus made his formal call to them saying,
Come, follow me, and I will make you fishers of men. (Matthew 4:19)
And when they heard it, they left everything to follow him.
What can we get from this?
First, Jesus’ grace extends to us and covers all our sins and failures, just like it covered Peter’s. He didn’t condemn Peter for his sin. Rather, he called Peter into a new life.
Second, you don’t need special qualifications to follow Jesus. You don’t need to go to seminary or Bible school. Peter and his friends were simple, uneducated fishermen. But Jesus called them anyway as his primary disciples.
Third, the most important thing for us to do is to trust him and to obey him. We don’t need to understand all the whys for the things Jesus asks us to do.
But we do need a heart that says, “But because you say so, I will.” We need a heart that is willing to let go of everything we hold dear in order to follow him.
Finally, as his followers, we are called to join in Jesus’ work. To bring others into the kingdom of God.
Will you be like Peter and his friends. Will you follow the Master’s call?